Choosing the right urinal matters whether you’re outfitting a garage, RV, campsite, or small bathroom. We tested a range of portable and wall-mounted models — from budget bedside bottles to flush-capable commercial units — and combined hands-on testing with expert feedback and user reviews to recommend the best options for different needs.
How we tested and chose
What we evaluated
- Real-world use: installation ease, splash control, odor control, and cleaning.
- Build quality and materials: durability in indoor/outdoor conditions and UV or chemical resistance.
- Functionality: hose compatibility, mounting options (screw vs. no-drill), and whether a flush interface or lid is available.
- Value signals: included accessories (hose, screws, odor pads), dimensions, and whether the product suits composting or medical use.
Process
- Hands-on testing of installation and cleaning on representative surfaces.
- Odor and splash trials in controlled settings, plus long-term inspection for staining or degradation.
- Surveyed verified user reviews and cross-checked manufacturer specs for reliability claims.
The final picks balance performance, price, and everyday practicality.
Glow-Lid Bedside Urinal
A simple, ultra-affordable bedside urinal with a glow-in-the-dark lid for night use. Lightweight and spill-resistant, it’s a practical medical or travel aid for home care where low cost and straightforward function are priorities.
Why it made the list
The Medline bedside urinal is the go-to budget option for caregivers and travelers. It’s made from straightforward molded plastic and features a glow-in-the-dark lid for easy nighttime access. During testing it performed reliably for bedside use: easy to grip, quick to clean, and robust for repeated handling.
Pros
- Extremely low price and simple design.
- Glow lid helps locate it at night without lights.
- Familiar medical-grade pedigree.
Cons
- Not designed for wall mounting or outdoor use.
- No hose or composting features; capacity is modest compared to camping bottles.
shawoo Flushable Wall Urinal
A premium wall-mounted urinal with a reserved flush interface, long sewer hose, and odor pad. Suited to garages, dorms, or small bathrooms where you want a compact, flush-capable installation and upgraded odor control.
Why it made the list
This shawoo model is the most feature-rich option we tested. It offers a reserved spray/nozzle port for optional flushing, a 57-inch sewer hose (ID ~1.26 in) for flexible routing, and an aromatic pad to reduce smells. The larger molded bowl and top-mounted nozzle deliver better rinsing when connected to water; the compact footprint suits tight spaces.
Pros
- Flush-ready design for a near-traditional clean.
- Includes long flexible hose and odor-control pad.
- Multiple wall-mounting options (suction or screws) make installation adaptable.
Cons
- Pricier than simple waterless models.
- Requires a water source to realize full flush benefits; otherwise functions as a waterless unit with reduced rinse.
Waterless Outdoor Urinal
A compact, UV-resistant waterless urinal designed for outdoor and garage use. Comes with a 1.5 m hose and screws, installs easily on fences or walls, and helps save water while directing urine for composting or disposal.
Why it made the list
This model delivers strong everyday value: durable UV-resistant plastic, a 1.5 meter hose (32 mm diameter), and mounting hardware all included for about thirty dollars. Installation is simple — screw to a wall or fence — and the sloped bowl and hose attachment make composting or contained collection straightforward. In tests it showed good splash control and low maintenance needs.
Pros
- Excellent accessory set for the price (hose + screws).
- UV-resistant for outdoor durability.
- Simple, low-maintenance waterless operation saves water.
Cons
- Basic odor control relies on placement and collection method; no aroma pad.
- Not suited for users who need a sealed, medical-grade container.
Adjustable Waterless Urinal
A versatile wall-mounted plastic urinal with an adjustable height, long hose, and spill-proof design. Suitable for garages, campers, and composting setups — ideal when you need flexibility for different users or locations.
Why it made the list
Stock Your Home’s waterless urinal is our Editors' Choice for versatility. It blends a user-friendly shape and spill-proof opening with adjustable mounting height, a long 61-inch hose, and straightforward installation. It’s roomy enough for adult use, and the sloped bucket/hose design makes composting or bucket collection simple. In wear-and-tear checks it remained stable and easy to clean.
Pros
- Adjustable height works for men, boys, and multi-user environments.
- Long hose and good spill-proof geometry for composting or contained disposal.
- Simple installation with included screws.
Cons
- Slightly higher price than the most basic waterless options.
- No dedicated odor pad—users may want to add one for indoor settings.
Comparison at a glance
- Best Budget Pick (Medline) — Lowest-cost bedside option; ideal for medical/bedside use and night-time convenience (glow lid).
- Premium Choice (shawoo Flushable Wall Urinal) — Highest-feature unit with optional flush interface, long sewer hose, and odor pad; closest to a small commercial urinal.
- Best Value for Money (Waterless Outdoor Urinal) — Strongly priced outdoor/garage solution with included hose and hardware; UV-resistant and low maintenance.
- Editors Choice (Adjustable Waterless Urinal) — Most versatile: adjustable height, long hose, and spill-proof design for varied use cases.
Key technical differences
- Hose length and diameter: Premium and many wall models include ~57" hoses with ~1.26" ID; the value model lists a 1.5 m hose with 32 mm diameter.
- Mounting: Some products provide both suction/no-drill and screw options; the bedside and travel bottles are handheld and not mountable.
- Flush capability: Only the premium flush-ready models include reserved interfaces for connecting a water supply.
Best overall: the shawoo flushable wall urinal if you want the closest experience to a conventional urinal with rinse capability and stronger odor control. For most users seeking simple outdoor/garage solutions, the waterless outdoor urinal delivers the best balance of price and included accessories.
Final recommendation
Our testing shows there’s no single perfect urinal — the best choice depends on your scenario:
- For bedside or medical needs on a tight budget, choose the Glow-Lid Bedside Urinal (Medline).
- For a near-traditional, flush-capable install with robust odor management, the shawoo Flushable Wall Urinal is the premium pick and our top overall recommendation.
- If you want solid performance for garage, shed, or outdoor use without spending much, the Waterless Outdoor Urinal is the best value.
- For flexibility across users and mounting environments, the Adjustable Waterless Urinal (Editors Choice) is the most versatile.
We based these recommendations on hands-on testing, user feedback, and technical specs — prioritizing ease of installation, odor and splash control, durability, and value. If you tell us your primary use case (indoor bedside, garage, RV, or composting garden), we’ll point you to the single best match for your needs.